Jump to content

No back spring in landing gear actuators


Recommended Posts

This is what was referred to by Premier. We posted to share our experience. We also pointed out that Premier was an FAA Repair Station and perhaps that factored into their interpretation/position.

 

I reiterate that Mooney has since changed this in their Service Manual, and it's no longer in Chapter 4. The part has been changed, and we have a new part. It was expensive, and arguably unnecessary. At the time, we had no choice.

 

As a side note, the airplane also has Amsafe airbags. The module which controls its deployment (in the belly of the airplane) apparently is also a time limited part, and our module had reached that time limit. When we elected to defer the replacement of the module Premier, disconnected it (but did leave it installed in the airplane), put a placard "Amsafe Disabled" and a notation in the annual entry in the aircraft logbook.

 

We are only relating our experience, nothing more. We are not being judgmental. Again, Premier elected to become an FAA Repair Station. Perhaps the set of rules under which they now fall gives them no leeway. This certainly exceeds any knowledge I have. Perhaps one needs to consider the possible ramifications if a conveniently located MSC becomes an FAA Repair Station, when considering an annual or other service.

Chapt 4 Mooney Service Manual.pdf

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is what was referred to by Premier. We posted to share our experience. We also pointed out that Premier was an FAA Repair Station and perhaps that factored into their interpretation/position.

 

I reiterate that Mooney has since changed this in their Service Manual, and it's no longer in Chapter 4. The part has been changed, and we have a new part. It was expensive, and arguably unnecessary. At the time, we had no choice.

 

As a side note, the airplane also has Amsafe airbags. The module which controls its deployment (in the belly of the airplane) apparently is also a time limited part, and our module had reached that time limit. When we elected to defer the replacement of the module Premier, disconnected it (but did leave it installed in the airplane), put a placard "Amsafe Disabled" and a notation in the annual entry in the aircraft logbook.

 

We are only relating our experience, nothing more. We are not being judgmental. Again, Premier elected to become an FAA Repair Station. Perhaps the set of rules under which they now fall gives them no leeway. This certainly exceeds any knowledge I have. Perhaps one needs to consider the possible ramifications if a conveniently located MSC becomes an FAA Repair Station, when considering an annual or other service.

 

I purchased my plane through Premier and they did an annual and top overhaul prior to the delivery.  I enjoyed my transaction with them and I found them to be good and honest people.  The maint shop quality was reasonable (not perfect)!  I will buy from them again if they are selling what I am looking for.

 

I also have an issue with the specification that is hour based.  I bought the plane used and not sure if someone did hundreds of T&G with the gear going up and down or the time is built up in multiple long cross county flights, so the safest thing is to put a new one on and not worry about it.

 

I called Top Gun again today regarding no-back spring.  They recommend to replace it at 1000 hours until Mooney officially changes the requirement.  I will be happy to spend the $1100 and not worry about a belly landing with my family onboard.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What is the time/age limit of the AmSafe airbags?

I have some old cars, I'm starting to wonder about...

I'll probably leave them connected though while I find out....

Best regards,

-a-

The recommendation used to be to have the airbags checked 10 years from manufacture. Just like the Cirrus chute, rocket and (unfortunately) straps buried inside the skin.

I would imagine that AmSafe's timeline is similar, but you'll need to confirm.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

airbags timed out at 10 years huh...so they disable a potentially life saving device that may or maynot work due age.Well now you know Deb it definitely wont work!!...I am really having trouble understanding their thinking...are they concerned about an unwanted deployment?..Does amsafe recomend this action?I know if this was my bird..I would have the belly panels off and control module reconnected and the placard removed until I got another opinion..and of course Premier gave you no option and made a log book entry.This is the kinda thing Mike Busch at savvy aviator deals with...I was nuetral in this discussion until I heard about the airbags!!Sorry for your treatment Deb...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 5 months later...

I heard Mooney may increase the recommended 1000 hour replacement on no back spring clutch in the landing gear motor assemblies to 2000 hours but add an inspection at 1000 hours. Does anyone have any info on this?

 

Do the new Acclaim or Ovation need the no-back-spring done after a 1000 hours?

 

I posted this a long time ago.  I am wondering if there is a news on this?

 

Driver 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When I purchased my used Ovation from Premier, they replaced the no back spring without charge to me as it was a SB.

 

How may hours did you have on the no-back spring?  I bought mine from Premier with 884 hours and still had the original no back spring.  

I have now over 1000 hours and while it is not mandatory, I will replace it for a piece of mind.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How may hours did you have on the no-back spring?  I bought mine from Premier with 884 hours and still had the original no back spring.  

I have now over 1000 hours and while it is not mandatory, I will replace it for a piece of mind.

Save me your old spring ! :-)

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

There may be some truth to what they said IF the work was done under their repair station license.  I worked at a FAA repair station for several years and our overhaul procedures for several of our gear actuators said the removed parts had to be destroyed period.  We had a press set up to crush them.  Because it was in our procedures it had to be done. It all depends on what their written procedures say and IF the work was signed off as a repair station or by an A&P.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes the old repair station scam. Every component must leave here in new condition and no IRAN. The local prop shop refused to repaint and balance my prop. Claimed since it was past 6 years it "must be overhauled or it's not airworthy". How much then. 7 grand they grind the blades "hopefully they'll pass". For a 9 year old 1250 hour McCauley prop.

My friend went with them for his bellanca prop and 3 months 100 hours later all 3 blades are leaking. They tore it down for warranty and they told him the blades must be re-profiled but they are at limits. 13k a new prop he was flying again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 7 months later...

Mooney did not change its recommendation so I now have a tested no-back-spring in my tool box :)

I replaced my spring at 1140 hours and had to replace the clutch as well.  I used a high mag microscope to check the two ends of the spring and see of there was any signs of cracking and none was found.  it was interesting see that one side was near perfect but the second end was showing signs of deterioration of the edges of the spring as well as a few deep scratches.

I will keep my eyes and ears open for the infant mortality case but it still think I made the right decision to replace it.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mooney Service Manual MAN170 issued November 1998 "This handbook includes the maintenance information required to be available by FAR PART23"

Chapter 5 TIME LIMITS/MAINTENANCE CHECKS

5-10-01 OVERHAUL, MAINTENANCE AND REPLACEMENT SCHEDULE

RECOMMENDED OVERHAUL, MAINTENANCE OR REPLACE TIME LIMITS

Landing Gear - Actuator No-Back Spring .... 1000 Hours

the next item on the list is Powerplant

Engine ....... 2000 Hours.

and 

Propeller ..... 2000 Hours

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Cruiser said:

Mooney Service Manual MAN170 issued November 1998 "This handbook includes the maintenance information required to be available by FAR PART23"

Chapter 5 TIME LIMITS/MAINTENANCE CHECKS

5-10-01 OVERHAUL, MAINTENANCE AND REPLACEMENT SCHEDULE

RECOMMENDED OVERHAUL, MAINTENANCE OR REPLACE TIME LIMITS

Landing Gear - Actuator No-Back Spring .... 1000 Hours

the next item on the list is Powerplant

Engine ....... 2000 Hours.

and 

Propeller ..... 2000 Hours

So, is this contained in the airworthiness limitations section or not?  Cirrus has one, and the Items therein are not optional.  But it's a FAR 23 aircraft.  

There seems to be a debate on whether SB's are now mandatory.  I have no idea why  

 

Edited by jetdriven
Link to comment
Share on other sites

36 minutes ago, jetdriven said:

So, is this contained in the airworthiness limitations section or not?  Cirrus has one, and the Items therein are not optional.  But it's a FAR 23 aircraft.  

There seems to be a debate on whether SB's are now mandatory.  I have no idea why  

 

My understanding is that the no back spring and SBs are not mandatory and my mechanic agrees.  I usually comply since most are not too difficult to comply with.  I will not overhaul the engine or prop at TBO and that decision will be based on the condition of the units, not the hours.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.