Option creep enters into the equation and you can buy two early J's for the cost of one 252. A turbo aircraft has the option of flying above icing and in clear air, but it doesnt come cheap. If you discount the engine, prop, and accesory reserve (something approaching twice a 201, or around 25$ an hour), the costs are quite similar. Eventually that 40K bill comes due, however. Just be prepared.
Also, our useful load is 974 LB. A friend of ours has a '79 231 and his useful is I believe 800 lb. So, taking more than two people, we can go farther on one fuel stop or at least the same, and the time advantage of the 231 disappears.
Still, the 201 doesnt have much reserve climb ability at 10,000' and it would be nice to have some forced atmosphere to the engine. A 252 is still cheaper than a Bonanza, too