Don,
With all due respect, there’s nothing definitive about your cylinder shop’s statement. “More issues from cylinders coming from engines that use camguard”. I would be skeptical of anyone who made unqualified statements like that. If Camguard is causing these “issues”, then why are your other three cylinders running strong? Perhaps the other three should be overhauled as a precautionary measure? The genesis of most old wives tale can be traced to credentialed professionals making foolish statements about subject ancillary to their area of expertise. It’ll be interesting to see how long it takes for this one to spread.
In the meantime, if you have any excess Camguard on the shelf consider selling it cheap (i’ll take it off your hands). Statistically speaking, having a bottle in your hangar is probably as detrimental to cylinder health as having a bottle in your engine. You can’t be too careful.