It is a wonderful place. I have flown the Mooney there many times over the last 15 yrs. The Aeroclub also has slightly cheaper fuel.
Used to be a member in the aero club that had a 231, he sold it several years ago. The paper work on landing and departure can be painful, but with the help of the Aero Club you can do well.
Both Tikal and MGGT are safe airports. As always, have plenty of fuel on arrival as it is only one runway and we all know runways are shut down for various reasons.
Lastly, for those that cannot make it non stop from Key West or the Texas border, the Aero Club used to have an agreement with Mexico, Chetemal and Cozumel for a safety Fuel stop. This enabled you to land without any customs, buy fuel and take off.
You will need to obtain in advance the document, if still available, from the Aero Club. I never personally used it, but know others have and it was accepted as described by Mexico.