We need to be really clear about the legal governance issues surrounding AOPA and what rights we as members have - and don't have. AOPA is a trustee-led 501C3 corporation - it is not a member-managed organization with a board of directors, like EAA. As a member of AOPA, we have zero governance oversight. Our proxies are not used for voting. They are only for quorum purposes. Witholding your proxy is meaningless. There are no rights associated with it and we cant just give our proxy to someone else not on the Board of Trustees, because that doesnt exist as a thing.
As "members" we get the right to be customers - and that is it. We get the magazine, the legal services plan access, lapel wings, and other benefits, including representation. We have NO governance authority at all as members, and no say in how the Corporation is run.
Think of it like being a member of Costco.....
The more serious long term issue is that AOPA could be diminished in its clout in Congress as a result of all of this. You can criticize them for not acting on this issue or that, but I have been to many AOPA events where there were one or more congressmen in attendance - that kind of attention doesnt come easily. if we lose that kind of power, that is not good for anyone. Our industry needs a strong AOPA. Every 10 years there is an existential threat and if AOPA isnt there, the tanks roll through the fence - look at things like privatization, and GARA - infrequent threats or opportunities, but you have one shot to get it right or bad stuff happens.
I don't know how this resolves itself, but the outcomes and long term unintended consequences are scary.