Lol. Maybe so.
However, he is far from ignorant of planes and flying is his life. Somehow, some way he has come to that conclusion. There has to be a reason for it. Right?
Case in point...and maybe a good analogy...I have spent 3/4 of my life on cycles and spent the last 15 years restoring old Harleys. Now, many will say there are certain years (AMF) that are plain crap, not worth touching. And there is a lot of truth in that...if you were back in the 70's. But now and if you bought one, they have likely been fixed/modified and brought up to speed and can be a great cycle. Point being...there was/still is a very dark cloud over certain years in that history.
I just don't follow the extreme differences in price between an F and J and, granted, I am taking one person's opinion who has ~1000 hrs in several Mooney types.
I just want to buy a plane that will serve me for many years. I am the type tat likes to get one thing and get to know it very well so it is second nature. I am sure I am not alone in that.
I also don't want to buy something I don't need. I am sure others are just as cautious.